February 15, 2021

Big Flakes and Little Flakes During the Weekend Snow. Why?

A number of you sent me emails about the snowflakes over the weekend.

Why were the flakes so SMALL Saturday morning?  Tiny flakes!

And then they got much bigger Saturday afternoon and on Sunday.  Why?

To see what they mean, here is an image of the snow falling Sunday morning. BIG FLAKES!  Similar on Saturday afternoon


But an image Saturday morning had snow so small you could barely see it! But snow was piling up.


There is a reason for this difference.  The size, shape, and structure of ice and snow crystals vary with temperature, humidity and vertical motion in the atmosphere.

So let's do some ice crystal 101!

Snow begins with ice crystals that form when water vapor freezes on to small ice nuclei (small particles) in the atmosphere.  This is a process called deposition.  

Because of its molecular structure, water vapor produces six-sided ice crystals (hexagonal if you want to impress your friends).

It turns out the structure of the ice crystals (also called ice crystal habit) depends on temperature and humidity (see figure).

Check out the figure below.  On one axis is temperature.  On the other is something called supersaturation.   When air rises, it can cool and can become saturated (100% relative humidity).  But believe or not, with strong upward motion, the relative humidity can increase ABOVE 100%.  Amazing.  Relative humidity above 100% is called supersaturation.

Keep in mind that ice crystals form high in the atmosphere, where conditions are cooler than at the surface.


Back to the figure.  For relatively warm temperatures (-10 to 0°C), the ice crystals are generally small and in the form of plates and cylinders.  

But if temperatures aloft are in a magical zone from roughly -12 to -18C and supersaturation is high (which means strong upward vertical motion), giant dendrites can form.  This is known in the weather business as the Dendritic Growth Zone (DGZ).  For these conditions, the atmosphere is at maximum efficiency for forming ice crystals and snow.  Cooler temperatures result in more of the smaller columns and plates.

And there is something else: when big snowflakes forming in cold air aloft fall into warmer--near freezing or above freezing air in the lower atmosphere they can start melting or become "stickier".  They can hit and join together into giant snowflakes in a process call aggregation

So now you are ready to understand what happened over the weekend!

We can start with the simulated model sounding from the UW forecasting system, showing how temperatures and moisture (dew point) varied with height at 4 AM Saturday morning, when the small snow crystals were falling.   Temperature is on the x-axis (°C) and height is in pressure (700 is around 10,000 ft).  Temperature is shown by red line and dew point by blue.  
When temperature and dew point overlap, the air is saturated (you need that to produce snow!).   I have indicated with two dashed lines the temperatures good for big dendritic crystals to form (the Dendritic Growth Zone).


The strong forcing and saturation at this time (Saturday morning) were BELOW the DGZ (see arrow).  In fact the air was not even saturated at the altitude of the DGZ.     Good for the growth of small crystals like we saw.   

And temperatures were below freezing near the surface, so not good for snow to stick together (aggregation).

But now  let's check out the vertical sounding predicted for that afternoon when big snowflakes were falling.  The air had become saturated in the critical temperature zone of the DGZ...so more big snow crystals!  And there was lots of warming near the surface--even above freezing. So the falling big crystals would get stick and aggregate together in big snowflakes....just like we saw!  No wonder the snowflakes were bigger.


The bottom line is that  the type of snowflakes reaching the surface depends on temperature and humidity aloft, which are controlled by many things, including the strength of upward motion in the atmosphere and the changes in temperature and moisture produced by the winds aloft.

There are definitely some little folks that are disappointed that the snow is now melting....



______________________________________
Public Radio Station KNKX and Cancel Culture

If you are interested in learning more about public radio station KNKX and cancel culture, check out my new blog/website on the issue: https://knkxcancel.blogspot.com/2021/02/knkx-and-cancel-culture.html


14 comments:

  1. monitoring changes in flake type and size falling onto a snowboard is a fun way to assess changes in the air column above ...

    ReplyDelete
  2. I always thought snowflakes were based on temperature alone. I had no idea about the other explanation, which I still don't understand; however, I'll read this post several times, and hopefully grok more of your explanation.

    Looks like I'm in for another two week thaw (ugh) and I notice weather.com is predicting more snow right around when my property will thaw. Hopefully, they're upper temp forecasts will hold.

    Thanks for the snowflake teaching.

    A month until spring, my favorite season.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Don't you also sometimes have rime ice forming on dendrites?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Cliff, what role does evaporation/sublimation play in the size of snowflakes that reach the ground? Thursday, the Doppler showed light snow here in the Kent area all day, but nothing reaching the ground. When a few flurries would make it, they were tiny.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Like that chart - I never knew! Where would graupel fit in the chart? I think it's the most curious form of snow. Also what about hail? Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Further note on my comment: The snow had to fall through strong, dry easterly winds.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thank you! Fascinating. But a question remains that I've always had, often asked, and never found a satisfying answer to: I appreciate the hexagonal structure of ice crystals as it relates to the molecular geometry of water. But in the formation of large dendritic flakes, what maintains the macroscopic symmetry? I imagine that as the crystal grows, molecules of water freeze out of the vapor, but if a there is growth on one edge of the flake, why does the identical growth occur symmetrically at the other six (or 12!) positions on the flake. It has always seemed like spooky action at a distance, somehow. If you can address this mystery at some convenient time, I would be most appreciative. Thank you again, for all you do.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Can you explain how it is that Whatcom County got. Measly four inches. I’m tired of being cheated while being clobbered with those BRUTAL BONE BITTER ARCTIC WINDS. I know you can’t stop it. But darn it. It seems we get cheated every year. And we are further north.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The latest weather loops seem to indicate that there is some possibility of more snow next week. If as predicted by the models the coldest part of the polar vortex will be near Eastern Alaska and Western Canada as shortwaves move over the top of a ridge through Alaska and down the coast, it seems as if there is a possibility that it might get colder than it was over the weekend when shortwaves moved through a ridge as it weakend. The models also seem to indicate that after the snow ends there might be clearing skies and even colder temperatures.

    ReplyDelete
  10. @robduisberg: excellent question and one that's lurked in the background for me as well. Found some helpful info at the first answer here:
    https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/3795/why-are-snowflakes-symmetrical

    ReplyDelete
  11. There are almost 100 different classifications of freezing precipitation (sleet, snow grains, snow pellets, etc.). As an ex air traffic controller I had to memorize all of them. Weather tests were always the most difficult. Weather is mostly memorization.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thank you, AndrewM. That link leads to an excellent article. It's particularly helpful to see in the detailed close up photos that the symmetry is *not exact* as I had thought, and that supports the notion that the symmetry (and variety!) arises from depositions in various temp/pressure/humidity conditions, which are the same over the dimensions of the growing flake, but change over time. Nice. Again, thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  13. The world must know this, because it is a good news, i am a happy man today i can do anything i want in life, because the illuminati brotherhood changed my life, after i have been scammed so many times, it was very terrible for me because i was in pains, i was falling because i have no one to help me, all my friends run away from me, that was when i believe it is very difficult to have a good friends, because i see it myself if i want to continue to tell everyone my storyline, it will take you days to read it, all i can say now is that the illuminati brotherhood is real, and the real illuminati brotherhood can never ask you to pay money to join, because it is totally free to join the illuminati brotherhood, i was scammed thousand of dollars that ruin my life and brought hard ship to my life, but i never give up because i know illuminati is real, i want you all to know that it is very difficult to find the real illuminati brotherhood, this is the reason why i said i will do my level best to help people out there who have been scammed so many times and who are interested to join the illuminati for change of life or etc, i want you to know it is real that the illuminati gives out this benefits, instant $2,000,000.00 Car of your choice, Mansion house of your choice, protection to you and your family, if really you have be finding away to join or you have being scammed so many times, i will direct you to the real illuminati brotherhood official email to contact on how to join the illuminati, email: thechurchofdevil@gmail.com or WhatsApp/Call/Text +1 (508) 819 2672 i want you all to know it is totally free to join the illuminati brotherhood, you are free to contact Email/WhatsApp or Text/Call on how to join the illuminati brotherhood, you must have to know this, Many will discourage you that it is a scam; but ask yourself how is it a scam when it is free of charge to join.

    ReplyDelete

Please make sure your comments are civil. Name calling and personal attacks are not appropriate.

What Controls the Movement of Wildfire Smoke? And a Perfect Forecast for the Next Week.

 We are now in wildfire season and the resulting smoke is on everyone's mind.  And the dramatic transcontinental movement of West Coast ...